The Greece community is grappling with renewed grief following the death of Kimberly Riesen, a 25-year-old resident of Hamlin, who passed away on January 27, 2026, from injuries sustained in a serious traffic collision earlier this month. Her passing marks the third fatality linked to a single devastating crash, deepening the sorrow felt across the area.
The collision occurred on January 17 at approximately 1 p.m. at the intersection of West Ridge Road and Elmgrove Road. According to authorities, a westbound vehicle operated by Craig Cavallaro, 42, of Parma, struck Riesen’s car while it was stopped at a red light. Cavallaro was pronounced dead at the scene.
Riesen and her passenger, Tyler Underwood, 28, also of Hamlin, were rushed to Strong Memorial Hospital with life-threatening injuries. Despite intensive medical care, Underwood later succumbed to his injuries. Riesen fought for several days before her passing, bringing the tragic toll of the crash to three lives lost.
The Greece Police Department confirmed that the investigation into the crash is ongoing. Officials are continuing to examine the circumstances surrounding the collision and have asked anyone with relevant information or nearby surveillance footage to assist investigators. No final determination on contributing factors has been released at this time.
In the wake of the tragedy, the community has rallied around the affected families, offering condolences and support. Local leaders have acknowledged the efforts of first responders and medical personnel who worked tirelessly in the immediate aftermath of the crash. Authorities are also using the incident as a reminder to motorists to remain vigilant, particularly at busy intersections.
As Greece mourns, residents are remembering Kimberly Riesen as a young woman whose life was cut tragically short, alongside Tyler Underwood and Craig Cavallaro. Their deaths have left a lasting impact, uniting the community in reflection, remembrance, and a shared commitment to road safety.